A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people!

A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people!

One of the famous objectors, and his followers made a diatribe in the
mass media, criticizing Muhammad's (PBUH) speech: " I was ordered to
fight people…"
They alleged that the messenger of Allah (PBUH) was ordered to fight all people!!
They resorted to what's mentioned in Al Bukhari and Muslim:
1 – The Correct Bukhari, book of (Faith), chapter (But if they should
repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way),
no. 24. Abdullah Ibn Muhammad Al Musnadi said: Abu Rouh Al Harmi Ibn
Omara said: Shouba narrated from Waqed Ibn Muhammad, said: I heard my
father narrated from Ibn Omar that the messenger of Allah (PBUH) said:
"I was ordered to fight people till they witness that there's no God but
Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, establish prayer,
and give zakah (alms). If they do so, they preserve their blood and
money from me, except by the right of Islam, and Allah will judge them".
2 – The Correct Muslim, book of (Faith), chapter (the order of fighting
people till they say there's no God but Allah and Muhammad is the
messenger of Allah), no. 30. Abu Al Taher, Harmala Ibn Yahia, and Ahmad
Ibn Eissa said: Ibn Wahb told us: Yunus narrated from Ibn Shehab that he
said: Saeed Ib Al Musaib narrated that Abu Huraira told him that the
messenger of Allah (PBUH) said: " I was ordered to fight people till
they say there's no God but Allah. He who says it preserves himself and
his money from me, except by his right, and Allah will judge him".
The reply:
First: the person who discusses this speech doesn't concern us.
Negligibles are too many, and there's no sin greater than disbelief.
Allah, the Almighty, says: {And thus have We made for every prophet an
enemy from among the criminals. But sufficient is your Lord as a guide
and a helper} (The Criterion: 31). As for this person's followers, I
say: as there're leaders who guide their followers to the good, there
are leaders who guide their followers to hell. Allah, the Almighty,
says: {And We made them leaders inviting to the Fire, and on the Day of
Resurrection they will not be helped} (The Stories: 41)
I call out at the followers of that man to search justly, in order not
to be doomed ; as Allah, the Almighty, doomed previous nations. He, the
Almighty, said about Pharaoh's and Haman's followers, who are their
soldiers and obey their orders without thinking: {Indeed, Pharaoh and
Haman and their soldiers were deliberate sinners} (The Stories:
It's mentioned in Al Jalalain interpretation: {Indeed, Pharaoh and
Haman} his minister {and their soldiers were deliberate sinners) from
sin means: contravenes, so they were punished.
Second: their claim, which says: the prophet (PBUH) was ordered to fight
all people, is false….It indicates that they're liars, why?
Because when I revised all the speech versions, I didn't find their claim…!
I have a question here: where did they find the word (all) in all the version?!
The answer: It's not found at all. It's only found in their shallow minds….
Therefore, this is a proof for their dishonesty and brain washing the public's minds.
Someone can ask: Who are the people that Muhammad (PBUH) was ordered to
fight, as he said: "I was ordered to fight people till they witness that
there's no God but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of
Allah……."?
I say: It's not logic to understand from this speech that he (PBUH) was
ordered to fight all people, because his companions, his wives, his
children were among "all people" and he (PBUH) didn't fight them….!
To clarify this, I will ask some questions about the Quranic verse, in
which Allah, the Almighty, says: {Those to whom the people said, 'The
people have gathered against you, therefore fear them', but it increased
them in faith, and they said, 'God is sufficient for us; an excellent
Guardian is He } (The Family of Imran: 173)
"Those to whom people said" who are those people? Are they all the people?
The answer: no, they're not all the people. It means: Naeem Ibn Masood
Al Ashjaey, only one man, and Allah, the Almighty, called him "people".
"The people have gathered against you" who are those people? Are they all the people?
The answer: no, they're not all the people. It means: Abu Sufian and his friends. "have gathered against you" to weed you out.
Thus Naeem Abu Masood Al Ashjaey, and Abu Sufian, and his friends are not all the people.
In consequence, Muhammad's (PBUH) speech: "I was ordered to fight people…." means: "to fight a certain group of people".
In his book, Al Fateh, Ibn Hajar, clarifies this saying: the word is
general and has specific meaning. So, in his (PBUH) speech: "to fight
people" means: the disbelievers (not the Christians and the Jews). This
is proved by Al Nasaee's narration: "I was ordered to fight the
disbelievers".
Allah, the Almighty, says: {Fight those who do not believe in Allah or
in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His
Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth
from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the
jizyah willingly while they are humbled} (The Repentance: 29)
Thus, Muhammad (PBUH) wasn't ordered to fight all the disbelievers, as
this did never happen. He (PBUH) was ordered to fight the leaders of
disbelief, who used to torture the righteous people, combat Allah's
religion, and stand as an obstacle in Muhammad's way in inviting people
to Islam, so that he (PBUH) saves the weak from hellfire and leads them
to heaven….
Third: after clarifying the group of people meant in Muhammad's
speech…There's an important question: why did the prophet (PBUH) fight
them?
The answer is in the rest of the speech: "till they witness that there's
no God but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah,
establish prayer, and give zakah (alms). If they do so, they preserve
their blood and money from me, except by the right of Islam, and Allah
will judge them".
Therefore, he (PBUH) didn't fight them except after inviting them kindly
to obey Allah's, the Almighty, orders, and letting them choose between
Islam, or the Jizia (taxes), if they're Christians and Jews, or fight.
If they choose fighting, that was reluctantly to Muslims, Allah, the
Almighty, says: { Fighting has been enjoined upon you while it is
hateful to you} (The Cow: 216)
So, he (PBUH) fights the leaders of disbelief, in order to let people
worship Allah, the Almighty, and save their followers from hellfire. He
(paid) the price for this from his (PBUH) and his companions' blood and
remains.
As a result, he (PBUH) didn't fight the leaders of disbelief for the sake of money, position, or leadership….
On the contrary, he fought them "till they witness that there's no God
but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, establish
prayer, and give zakah (alms)".
Then, this is a proof for his (PBUH) complete mercy with the
disbelievers, as he (PBUH) saves them from hellfire by Islam, after
letting them choose between the three options previously mentioned….
Besides, he (PBUH) didn't fight the leaders of disbelief by own self, but by Allah's, the Almighty, order.
Ibn Hajar mentioned, in his book, Al Fateh, his words "I was ordered"
means: Allah, the Almighty, ordered me, as no one can order a prophet
except Allah, the Almighty. And when a companion says: "I was ordered",
this means: the messenger of Allah (PBUH) ordered him, and can never
mean that another companion did that.
Thus, this was an obligation for Muhammad, because Allah, the Almighty,
knew that they wouldn't believe, so He, the Almighty, let his prophet
(PBUH) know it. In opposition to what the objectors understand, he
(PBUH) didn't order his followers to fight by his own will.
Fourth: there's a big difference between "fight" and "kill".
The first means: exerting an effort to stop an enemy from harming me.
The second means: eradicating the enemy.
No doubt that the speech mentions the first word.

by:dr. akram hassan morsi
Translation to English: Professor Islamic translation

جزاكِ الله كل خير درتنا الغالية
تسلم أناملك على النقل الطيب
الله لا يحرمنا جميل اختياراتك
وروعة مواضيعك
ممنونك كتيييييييييييييييير
A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people! 2061411786

A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people! 2061411786

بارك الله فيك

خيييتو جزاك الله كل الخييييير
هنيئا للمنتدي لاحتوائه علي عضو مزج بين رقي الاسلوب والاختيار في الطرح

يعطيك العافية أختى الفاضله لروعة ما طرحتى ،
ودي واحترامي لشخصك المميز
.
.
.
ملحوظه ,,,استعنت بجدو جوجل علي الترجمه لاني شطورة,ههههههههههه

» A Message to who does not believe in Prophet Muhammad

A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people!

A prophet says: I was ordered to fight people!

مواضيع مماثلة

مواضيع مماثلة